Capabilities

Consumer survey expert: Daubert-compliant survey design and rebuttal of opposing surveys.

Design and rebuttal of consumer surveys for Lanham Act, false advertising, trade dress, and consumer protection matters. Every major methodology — Eveready, Squirt, secondary meaning, dilution, net deception — with a track record of admitted testimony and opposing-survey exclusion.

Method 1

Likelihood of Confusion — Eveready

Unaided recall and recognition, brand associations, and source-of-origin testing. Appropriate stimulus, control, universe definition, and respondent screening. Daubert-grade documentation.

Method 2

Likelihood of Confusion — Squirt

Parallel-stimulus array methodology for direct-side-by-side comparison, with appropriate control stimuli and universe definition. Used when reverse confusion or direct market overlap is at issue.

Method 3

Secondary Meaning & Acquired Distinctiveness

Consumer-association surveys to demonstrate secondary meaning in trade dress or descriptive marks. Longitudinal or cross-sectional designs with attention to mark strength.

Method 4

Likelihood of Dilution

Fame and blurring analysis. Consumer recognition and association testing with appropriate distinctiveness and similarity thresholds.

Method 5

False & Deceptive Advertising

Net-impression and literal-falsity analysis, claim substantiation, materiality to purchase decisions. Net-deception percentages calibrated to control groups.

Method 6

Methodological Rebuttal

Identification of survey design flaws: leading questions, inadequate controls, improper universe, sampling bias, survey-demand artifacts.

“
Dr. Palmatier is an effective expert witness in the sales and marketing domain. I especially like that his background includes both executive business experience as well as an exceptional academic practice.
Avi J. Lipman · Attorney, McNaul Ebel Nawrot & Helgren PLLC
Survey Rebuttal Expertise

Editor-grade review of survey methodology.

Dr. Palmatier has performed hundreds of consumer surveys as a testifying expert and academic researcher, and has served as peer-review decision-maker on thousands of submitted papers during his editorial tenure at the Journal of Marketing and Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science. In that role, he would evaluate research for acceptable population definition, sample construction, control groups, and overall design integrity.

That editorial history makes a decisive difference in litigation. Reviewing an opposing survey is fundamentally the same exercise as reviewing a journal submission: identifying methodological flaws and pinpointing the sources of bias that make a finding unreliable. In practice this means systematic rebuttal of demand bias (leading or suggestive question wording), source bias (improperly defined universe, skewed sampling frame, inadequate screening), order and context effects, inadequate controls, and survey-demand artifacts.

The work is not abstract. In a published opinion, the Washington Court of Appeals recounted Dr. Palmatier’s rebuttal arguments and affirmed the exclusion of the opposing survey.

Published Opinion · Rebuttal Work Adopted

When a court excluded an opposing survey as “fundamentally flawed.”

In Robertson v. Valley Communications Center, the Washington Court of Appeals (Division I) affirmed summary judgment for the defendant based on three specific findings from Dr. Palmatier’s rebuttal.
1. Named
“VCC enlisted its own expert, Dr. Robert Palmatier, who prepared a critique of the survey.”
2. Adopted
The court based its decision on Dr. Palmatier’s two arguments: the “per shift” vs. “preshift” language distinction, and the finding that 18% of responses were logically impossible.
3. Excluded
“The trial court excluded a survey of class members and corresponding expert testimony as fundamentally flawed.”
Robertson v. Valley Communications Center, No. 80861-3-I (Wash. Ct. App. Div. I 2021) · Published Opinion · Summary Judgment for Defendant, Affirmed